European Journal of Business and Management ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol.10, No.15, 2018 How to Implementation of Organizational Citizensgip Behaviour with Performance on Accident Insurance Service?
How to Implementation of Organizational Citizensgip Behaviour with
Performance on Accident Insurance Service?
Mochamad Soelton Jaya Rakasidhi
Universitas Mercubuana
Abstract
The
research is to know the effect of training standard, Organizational Citizenship
Behaviour (OCB) on employee performance at. The object of the research is
employees who work at PT. JASARAHARJA (Persero). This research was conducted by
70 respondents using quantitative descriptive approach. Therefore, the data
analysis used is statistical analysis in the form of multiple linear regression
test. The result of the research indicates that partially and simultaneously
the standard variable of training, work attachment simultaneously have positive
and significant effect on employee performance, organizational Citizenship
Behaviour (OCB) have positive but not significant effect on employee
performance at PT. JASARAHARJA (Persero). This is evidenced from the result of
simultaneous tests (F test) and partial test results (t test) also show the
significant value of three independent
variables that support the hypothesis.
Keywords: Organizational Citizenship
Behaviour (OCB), Training Standard, and Employee Engagement, Performance
Backgraound
Knowledge
improvement to do a job in the future, conducted on the approach integrated
with other activities and in the same time hoped to change employees’
performances. Otherwise, training is conducted to improve employees’ skill and
ability to do their job technically. It is hoped that there will be emotional
interest and high intellectual quality between the employees and their job,
organization, manager, and their own work mates. So that it will encourage the
employees to do more for their job and the organization, Gomes (2010). Training
is an effort to make employees’ performance become better and better to their
jobs and their responsibilities or do the things related with their jobs. Here
are some purposes of education and training programs for employees : developing
work productivity, developing employees’ managerial ability, developing time
efficiency, reducing employees’ errors, developing public services, and
developing employees; carriers. Education and training programs conducted give
beneficial effects to the employees’ performance as individual. It is off
course will effect a great improvement for the employees’ performances if the
education and training are conducted systematically and continuously.
Organizational citizenship behaviour is an attitude to enrich and do better
than what a company hopes described as a formal or regular job. According to
Aldag and Resekhe in Clifton (2009) that Organizational Citizenship Behaviour
is an individual’s contribution do more than what a company requires him/her do
in his/her job. OCB includes some behaviours like being helpful for others,
being volunteer for extra duties, being obedient upon rules and procedures of
the company. These behaviours describe plus points for the employees which
includes in one of pro social behaviours which is positive social behaviour,
constructive and meaningful.
Schiemann (2009 ), employee engagement describes how far an employee’s
readiness to give more his power than minimal requirement asked by the
organization or to advocate the organization from other organizations as a
place to work or invest. An attached employee will work harder, stay at the
company longer, satisfies much more customers, and effect positively to the
company achievements. In reaching the company achievements, there are many
problems faced by the management related with the employees. For example about
compensation, disciplines, employees’ relationship, company external factors,
and many other things. Here is a Human Resources Development role to control
and keep employees’ harmonise. It will make mutual causative effects between
employees’ performances and the company.
From the total employees taken from the data of PT. Jasa Raharja inc.
from 2014 – 2017 shows that the employee engagement created well can give a
great empowering interpersonal relationship physically and psychologically so
that the employees can work more focus in doing their duties. A good training
standard will influence the employees; performance which will reach satisfying
achievement for the company. PT. Jasa Raharja experiences a very low turnover
development because of the employee engagment, and Organizational Citizenship
Behaviour (OCB). It can be said that the employees’ loyalty give great impact
to the employees’ performances of PT. Jasa Raharja. In the graphic, shows that
the employee engagement influences the level of employees’ performance, where
the employees will be satisfied if they are motivated, and given compensation.
It is to tie up the employees become more comfortable with the company.
Data of employees’ attendance based on the overdue attendances from
January – April 2017, data taken is from national data, shows that many
employees come late within a month. It may happen because of weakness of employees’ loyalty which causes the
employees feel unconformable in doing their job. Employees’
performance is one of the company considerations to be able to develop
the human resources. Because, the employees’ performance is really important in
increasing the employees’ productivity. To do the duties and responsibilities
are the expression of abilities and potentials belong to a person to have sense
of belonging in anyways. So, the employees’ performance will appear because of
the jobs and the duties they do in a line with the profession and jobs description.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Organization Citizenship Behavior (OCB)
Organization
Citizenship Behaviour (OCB) is discussed in literature organizational research
first time in the beginning of 1980 (s) (Bateman and Organ, 1983) Smith at
al.,1983;in Bienstock et al. Robbins said that Organizational Citizenship
Behaviour (OCB) is a chosen behaviour which does not include in regular or
formal duties of an employee, but it supports the function of organization
effectively ( 2006;31) Organizational Citizenship Behaviour is a willingness “
to work over the duties/responsibilities” or “to work extra” in a job.
Organizational Citizenship Behaviour is an extra role behaviour, or behaviour
to work over his/her duties or responsibilities. It is a behaviour that
describes what it is meant with Organizational Citizenship, the Organizational
citizenship related with the job satisfaction. According to Benhart in Kholid
and Ali (2005) Organizational Citizenship Behaviour (OCB) is defined as a
behaviour that can increase the value and keep social psychological environment
which supports job result.
A person is
a good Organization Citizen, will do things, although unrequired, will try to
help increasing the organization performance. A service officer for instance,
who will his extra time to serve the customers, a team member who wants to do
extra duties or a worker who always wants to be a volunteer to have overtime
without asking for extra payment, but just want to make sure that his duties
already done well. Johns in Budiharjo (2014) said that Organization Citizenship
Behaviour (OCB) has volunteer behaviour characteristic (extra role behaviour)
which does not include in a position, a spontaneous behavior without target or
someone’s requirements, a helpful behaviour, and a behaviour that cannot be
seen and evaluated based on the job evaluation. Organ, MacKenzie (2011)
integrated the construction of Organizational Citizenship Behaviour (OCB) into
7 constructional dimensions. They are : 1) Altruism, shows a behaviour to help
others sincerely and not his duties or responsibilities, 2) Sportsmanship, shows
a willingness or tolerances to keep working at an organization or company
without complaining though the company is in a bad condition, According to
Podsakoff (2012) the dimension is not fully concerned in empirical research, 3)
Organizational Compliance, shows an individual behaviour that accepts rules and
procedures made by the organization. This reflected by the individual behaviour
that never break the rules of the company although there is no supervision nor
fined, 4) Organizational loyalty, shows an individual behaviour that relates to
an effort to promote the organization image to others; in the other way he/she
ties to protect the organization from external pressures and keep working
at the
organization although it does not benefits him/her and full of risks, 5)
Civic Virtue, shows an individual participation in organization activities and
cares about the organization existence. Sincerely participates, responsible,
and takes a part in solving problems faced by the organization. He/she is also
active in delivering opinions and through his/her observation about business
environment whether about business obstacles or opportunities. 6)
Conscientiousness shows an individual behaviour that shows sincere effort to
improve ways in doing his/her duties creatively in order the organization
performance increases. The behaviour includes the creativity and innovation in
developing his/her capability to do his/her duties for increasing the
organization performance, 7) Self-development, is an individual behaviour which
relates to the efforts in developing knowledge, skill, and capability.
Employee Training
Standard
According
to Dessler (2009) a training is a process to teach and guide new employees or
the employees exist basic skill needed to do their job. So, the training
mentioned is a training in a very wide interpretation, not only on developing
the employees’ skill. There are some training methods usually conducted, they
are : on the job and off the job training (Hasibuan, 2005) : On the job
training (OT), also known as job instructional training is a training method
where the employees or prospective employees are put in the real job condition,
under control an supervision of the
trained and experienced employees. Off the job training, is the training occurs
when the trained employees do not do their regular job.
Work
Engagement
According
to Vazirani (2010) it is as a commitment level and engagement that the
employees have for the organization and the values in it that can be seen an
employee positive behavior upon the organization and the values in it.
According to Schicmann (2009), employee engagement shows how far an employee’s
willingness to do more than organization minimal requirements, more than
his/her role to give extra energy or advocate the organization from other
organization as a place to work or invest. An engaged employee will work harder
and
keep working
longer, satisfies much more customers, and gives positive influences to the
company achievements. Gallup Organization defines the engagement of employee an
individual engagement to an organization and working spirit, it is in a line
with Dernoysek (2008) he relates the employees’ engagement with positive
emotional engagement between
an individual and an organization and individual commitment to the organization.
Employees’
Performances
According
to Sedarmanyanti (2011) said that the employees’ performance is an application
of the output of what employees do, a process of managing or organizing, where
the output of the job can be shown concretely and be measured (compared with
the determined standard). According to Wibowo (2012), performance is a process
of how the job is being done to reach the job achievement. However, the output
of the job it shows the performance itself. According to Mangkunegara (2013),
employees’ performance is the output of the job in quality and quantity which
is reached by the employees to do the responsibilities given.
THE THEORITICAL
MODELS
1.
Does the Organization Citizenship Behavior (OBC) influence the
employees’ performances of PT. JASARAHARJA?
2.
Does the employee Training Standard influence the employees’
performances of PT. JASARAHARJA?
3.
Does the employee engagement influence the employees’ performances of
PT. JASAHARJA?
Based on the library research
and the previous research, the writer determines the theoretical framework as
follows:

Pict. 2.1 Theoritical
Frameworks
RESEARCH OBJECTIVE
To find the influences of Organizational Citizenship Behaviour (OCB),
employee Training Standard, and the employee engagement with the employees’
performances of PT. JASARAHARJA.
METHODOLOGY
The
research process begins with identifying the problems in the place to be used
the research location, formulation of identified problems, the collection of
basic theories that strengthen the foundations in the variables, the
preparation of the methods in data collection, the preparation of instruments,
to the determination of statistical testing techniques used in this research.
The writer uses the quantitative descriptive analysis, data analysis used that
is a research design of casual research for analysing the relationship between
one variable to other variables or how variable effects other variables. The
population in this research is at the office of PT. JASARAHARJA Jakarta. Period
July – December 2017. Determination of the sample used in this research using a
type of saturated sampling technique. The term of saturated is a census, where
all members of the problems are sampled. The design of analysis utilized in
this research using Multiple Regration analysis aims to see the effects between two independent variable
with one dependent variable. The statistical approach for this is through
multiple
linear regression analysis that is useful for determining the magnitude of the
influences between two or more variables at the same time looking at the level
of influences. This method is also commonly used to predict or predict the
value of the variable between more than one predictor variable (independent
variable) to the dependent variable.
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
Double Linear
Regression Test
Table 4.16
Result of double linear regression test Coefficientsa
Model
|
Unstandardized
Coefficients
|
Standardized
Coefficients
|
t
|
Sig.
|
|
B
|
Std. Error
|
Beta
|
|||
1 (Constant)
Work Training Standard Organizational Citizenship Behaviour
employee engagement
|
9,139
,360
,138
,290
|
3,861
,133
,108
,108
|
,314
167
,348
|
2,367
2,713
1,281
2,692
|
,021
,008
,205
,009
|
a.
Dependent Variable: employee Performances
Sources
: data tabulation of SPSS
Based on the table of data above using SPSS shows that the similarity
formulation of double linear regression for the independent variable (Work
Training Standard, Organizational Citizenship Behaviour, and employee engagement)
to the dependent variable (employees’ performance ) as follows : Y= 9,139 +
0,360 Work Training Standard + 0,138 OCB +0,290 work engagement.
Based on mathematical similarity of double linear regression can be
concluded that :
1.
The result of SPSS output identifies that value a (constant) is 9.139,
which means that without training standard, Organizational Citizenship
Behaviour and employee engagement influence the employees’ performances.
2.
Coefficient value b1X1(coefficient of training standard) is 0,360 which
means that the training standard can increase the employees’ performances.
3.
Coefficient value b2X2 (coefficient of Organizational Citizenship
Behaviour) is 0,138 which means that the Organizational Citizenship Behaviour
can increase the employees’ performances.
Coefficient value b3X3 (coefficient of Work engagement) is 0,290 which
means that the employee engagement can increase the employees’ performances.
Determination
coefficient test (R2)
Determination
coefficient is used to know how far the independent variables influence the
dependent variables. The value of determination coefficient is used adjusted R
square. Like shown in the table below :
Table 4. 17
The result of determination coefficient (R2)
Model Summaryb
Model
|
R
|
R Square
|
Adjusted R Square
|
Std. Error of the Estimate
|
1
|
.736a
|
,542
|
,521
|
2,630
|
a. Predictors: (Constant),
employee engagement , training standard, Organizational Citizenship Behavior
b. Dependent Variable: employee Performances Source : Data tabulation
using SPSS
Based on the table 4.17, it shows that the result of determination
coefficient (adjusted R2) is 0,521 which means 52,1% of employees’
performance can be explained from the three variables, they are training
standard, Organizational Citizenship Behaviour, and employee engagement. And
the rest 57,9% (100% - 52,1%) is explained by other variables unmentioned in
the research model like compensation, motivation, working environment, and
organisation commitment.
Accuracy Model Test
(Statistical Test F)
Statistical test F shows whether independent variables
mentioned in the model have the same influences to the dependent variables. The
result of statistical test F can be seen on table 4.18 as follows:
Table 4.18
Result of
accuracy model test (statistical test F)
ANOVAa
Model
|
Sum of Squares
|
df
|
Mean Square
|
F
|
Sig.
|
|
1
|
Regression
|
540,845
|
3
|
180,282
|
26,059
|
.000b
|
Residual
|
456,598
|
66
|
6,918
|
|||
Total
|
997,443
|
69
|
a. Dependent Variable :employee Performances
b. Predictors: (Constant), employee engagement , training standard,
Organizational Citizenship Behavior
Source: Data tabulation using SPSS
Based on the table 4.18 shows that significant probability 0,00 is that
probability less than 0,05, so the model is accepted that can be concluded that
training standard, Organizational Citizenship Behaviour, and employee
engagement influence the employees’ performances.
Partial
Significant Accuracy Test (Test T)
Statistical
test t basically shows how far the influences of dependent variables to
independent variables individually in describing variation of dependent
variables. Decision making can be done by looking at the probability. If
probability/significant > 0.05 Ho is accepted and Ha is rejected and if
probability/significant is <
0.05 Ho is rejected and Ha is accepted.
Table 4.19
Result of
partial significant accuracy test (Test t)
Coefficientsa
Model
|
Unstandardized
Coefficients
|
Standardized
Coefficients
|
t
|
Sig.
|
|
B
|
Std. Error
|
Beta
|
|||
1 (Constant)
Work Training Standard Organizational Citizenship Behaviour
employee engagement
|
9,139
,360
,138
,290
|
3,861
,133
,108
,108
|
,314
167
,348
|
2,367
2,713
1,281
2,692
|
,021
,008
,205
,009
|
a.
Dependent Variable: employee Performances
Source:
Data tabulation using SPSS
Based on the description
above, it shows that :
a.
Hypothesis test of training standard to the employees’ performances.
Based on the
table 4.20 significant probability of training standard 0.008 less than 0.05, so
Ho is rejected and Ha is accepted that is stated that partial of training
standard (X1) influences significantly to the employees’ performances.
b.
Hypothesis test of Organizational Citizenship Behaviour to the
employees’ performances.
Base on the
table 2.40 significant probability of Organizational Citizenship Behaviour is
0.25 less than 0.05, so Ho is rejected and Ha is accepted that is stated that
partial of Organizational Citizenship Behaviour (X2) influences significantly
to the employees’ performances.
c.
Hypothesis test of employee engagement to the employees’ performances.
Base on the
table 2.40 significant probability of employee engagement is 0.009 less than
0.05, so Ho is rejected and Ha is accepted that is stated that partial of employee
engagement (X3) influences significantly to the employees’ performances.
Result Discussion
1.
The influences of
Organizational Citizenship Behaviour to the employees’ performances.
Based
on the result of T test, it shows that value t calculated is 1.281 and
significant value is 0.250 more than
0.05. so, it can be concluded
that Organizational Citizenship Behaviour does not influence positively and
significantly to the employees’ performances.
It shows that a good Organizational Citizenship Behaviour or effort in
increasing Organizational Citizenship Behaviour does not influence the
employees’ performances. This means that hypothesis 2 is rejected. It is not in
a line with the research conducted by Puput Tri Komalasari, Moh. Nasih, and
Teguh Prasetio (2009) where Organizational Citizenship Behaviour does not
influence positively and significantly to the employees’ performances.
2.
The influences of training standard to the
employees’ performances.
Based on t
test that value t calculated is 2.713 and significant value is 0.008 less than
0.05. so it can be concluded that
variable of training standard influences significantly to the employees’
performances of PT. JASA RAHARJA head office. It shows that if the working
standard given by the company is good, it will increase and influence the
employees’ performances. It means that hypothesis 31 is accepted, and it is in
aline with the result of the previous research conducted by Denny Triasmoko,
Moch. Zudi Muksam Gunawan (2013) where the training standard influences
significantly to the employees’ performances.
3.
The influences of employee engagement to the
employees’ performances.
Based on t
test that value t calculated is 2.692 and significant value is 0.009 more than
0.05. so it can be concluded that variable of employee engagement influences
significantly to the employees’ performances of PT. JASA RAHARJA head office.
It shows that if the employees’ working engagement is good, it will increase
and influence the employees’ performances. It means that hypothesis 3 is
accepted, and it is in a line with the previous research conducted by Ronny H.
Mustamu (2016) where the employee engagement influences significantly to the
employees’ performances.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
Conclusion
1. Training standard influences positively and significantly to the
employees’ performances. It means that there must be development and
improvement of training standard so that it will be able to increase the
employees’ performances at PT. JASA
RAHARJA head office.
2. Organizational Citizenship Behaviour does not influence positively and
significantly to the employees’ performances. It means that all efforts of
increasing and performance and improving Organizational Citizenship Behaviour
will not increase the employees’ performances at PT. JASA RAHARJA head office.
3. Employee engagement influences positively and significantly to the
employees’ performances. It means that there must be improvement and increase
of employees’ working engagement to increase the employees’ performances at PT. JASA RAHARJA head office.
Recommendation
1.
Increasing indicator “loyalty” in an Organizational Citizenship
Behaviour. If the employees have a high loyalty so it will make the
Organizational Citizenship Behaviour which belongs to the employees will
increase, where we can help one another in doing our duties.
2.
Increasing indicator “purposes of training” in a training standard. By
understanding the purposes of the training, so the output of training conducted
can be more effective
3.
Increasing indicator “readiness” in a employee engagement. By having
the readiness to work, so that will increase the employees’ employee
engagement, and ready to have additional duties given.
REFERENCES
Agung AWS
Waspodo and Lussy Minadaniati (2012) "the influence of job satisfaction
and climate toward Organiational citizenship Behavior (OCB) employees at PT.
Trubus Swadaya Depok ". Journal of
Indonesian Science Management Research (JRSMI), 3 (1)
Agusta, Leonardo and Teddy Mediono sutanto. (2013)”The influence of
motivation training work on employee performance at CV Haragon Surabaya”. Jurnal,AGORA, 1 (3)
Ahmad Nizam
Mat Noor. (2013) “Human Resources Diversity Management Practices and
Organizational Citizenship Behavior; A
Conceptual Model”, Journal of Applied, 3 (8)
Chalida Rahmi A. Rahma Lubis (Mei 2015) “the influence of
Organizational Citizenship Behavior and job satisfaction on employee
performance, and Dessler, Gary (2009) management of human resources, book1,
Jakarta; index PPPP
Denny Triasmoko, Moch, Djudi Mukzam, and Gunawan Eko Nurthjahyono,
(2014) “ The influence of job training on employee (A research at employees of
PT. POS Indonesia (Persero) branch Kediri city ). paper VOL.12
Dharma,
A. (2010) Supervision Management: A Practical Guide for Supervisors. Jakarta:
Index
Gina Sheelsia Tampi, (Juni 2013)”Leadership and compensation and its
influence on employee performance and the effect to Organizational Citizenship
Behavior (OCB) at PT. Bangun Sentosa Bekasi ministry of social affairs RI”, “Journal EMBA;1 (3), 921-929
Ghazali Imam. 2011. Application of Multivariate analysis with SPSS
program. The forth copy, Semarang: Publisher of University of Diponegoro,
implication on employee performance statistic bureau distric of Aceh Besar and
Pidie,”Journal, 4 (2)PPP
Mangkunegara, Anwar Prabu AA (2009), Management of human
resources at companies. published. Bandung.
Publisher; PT Remaja
Rostakarya.
Mustamu, R.H. (2016). The influence of Employee engagement on employee performance at Human Capital Center
PT. Telekomunikasi Indonesia, Tbk. Journal Management Indonesia, Volume 14,(1),
page 47-58
Nabilah
Ramadhan and Jafar Sembiring, (2014). Effect of Employee Management on Employee Performance at Human Capital Center
PT. Telekomunikasi Indonesia, Tbk. Journal
of Management Indonesia, Volume 14, (1), Page 47-58
Nufus, H.
(2011), The influence of Organizational
Citizenship Behavior (OCB) on employee performance at PT. Putra Pertiwi
Karya Utama. paper.
Puput Trikomalasari, Moh. Nasih, and Teguh Prasetio. (2009) The
influence of motivation and Organizational
Citizenship Behavior on employee performance of government organization
using quantitative correlation analysis.
Rivai,
Veitzhal and Sagala, Elia Jauvani. (2010). Management
of human resources for companies from practical theory, Jakarta; PT. Taja
Grafindo.
Schiemann A.W. (2009)
Aligment Capability engagement, Jakarta PPM Management. Simamora, Henry.
(2010), Management of human resources.
STIE YKPN. Yogyakarta.
Soedjono (2011). The influence of Organizational culture on employee
performance and employee working satisfaction PT Terminal public passengers in
Surabaya. Journal management and
entrepreneurship Vol 7 (1)
Soeling, A,
A, (2013). The influence of Employee Engagement
on employee performance at PT Chandra Sakti Utama Leasing Jakarta. Paper.
Sugiyono: 2012 Research
methodology qualitative and quantitative and R&D. Bandung;Alfabet
Sunyoto, D,(2012), Management of human
resources; Yogyakarta:CAPS.
Sutrisno, Edi, (2009), Management of human resources, first edition.
Jakarta : Kencana Prenada Media Group. Thomas, T,H.(2011) A New Measurement
Scale For Employee Engagement: Scale Development, Pilot Test and
Replication. Academy
of Management Proceedings, pp.1-6
Umi Narimawati, 2008. Research methodology qualitative and
quantitative, theory and application, Bandung:Agung Media.
Vazirani, N.A.(2010) Employee
Engagement. Working Paper For SIES College of Management Studies, 2007 Wibowo
(2010) Management of performance,
third edition, Jakarta: Rajawali Press.
Wirawan. 2009.Evaluation
of human resources: Application and research theories. Jakarta Salemba
Empat.
x
x
Resume Journal :
Based on the research that has been done, it can be concluded as follows:
1.Training standard influences positively and significantly to the employees’ performances.
2. Organizational
Citizenship Behaviour does not influence positively and significantly to the
employees’ performances. It means that all efforts of increasing and
performance and improving Organizational Citizenship Behaviour will not increase the employees’ Resume Journal :
Based on the research that has been done, it can be concluded as follows:
1.Training standard influences positively and significantly to the employees’ performances.
Komentar
Posting Komentar